The headlines for the prewrite of Surflight’s “West Side Story” said the musical had “Audiences Screaming Their Applause” when it opened on Broadway in 1957 and then asked, “Could History Repeat Itself at Surflight?”

It did.

The show’s final scene is a somber one. Tony (Nathan Roberts) is shot and dies in Maria’s (Lizzy Perrone) arms. For a couple of minutes the audience was stunned – stone cold quiet. Not a word was spoken. It was as if everybody was holding their breath.