With the illumination of the original 40-foot-tall Barnegat lighthouse in 1835, the number of local shipwrecks decreased, and the stories of the Barnegat Pirates faded from the nation’s newspapers. Unfortunately the calm wasn’t to last. Lt. William Porter inspected the lighthouse just three years later and reported, “Barnegat light-house.-Burns eleven lamps, with parabolic reflectors placed on two parallel circles.