Things were eerily quiet in Beach Haven this past summer, and that had nothing to do with weather. By now everyone knows why. The landmark Surflight Theatre on Engleside Avenue went into bankruptcy in February and took its adjoining Show Place Ice Cream Parlour out of business with it. No more Broadway musicals or long lines waiting to get into a one-of-a-kind dessert place where customers were sometimes required to sing or dance, or both, for their ice cream.

The late Joseph P. Hayes, founder of Surflight, opened Show Place with a partner in 1975, because it was so near to his…