Colleen McNally believes “a witch is anybody who wants to make magic.” She doesn’t mean spells and potions or demonic practices. When she talks about the supernatural, she’s really talking about a human connection. “It’s me helping you tap into your own magic,” she said, chatting over tea at The Local in Ship Bottom this past Saturday morning, after soccer practice with her 8-year-old son, Max.

Now the 37-year-old mother, competitive power lifter and Beach Haven Borough employee is heeding the call she has long heard whispering to her, by teaching and reading Tarot cards at community and…