Sixteen-year-old Tyler Shay never thought the first people to request that he learn a song to sing and play for them on his acoustic guitar would actually come back to see him play at Mud City Crab House in Manahawkin two weeks later. When they did, he was a bit shell shocked.

“I was like, ‘whoa!'” Shay said, laughing. “I learn requests since then and play stuff people want to hear.”