Something magic happens after closing time at Bob’s Carpet Services in Barnegat at least twice a week. Pallets and displays are moved aside to make space for tables, and tournaments commence with all the sport of competitive poker – without all the gambling.

On Saturday, Chris Trotta hosted his largest Magic the Gathering tournament to date since his store, Trotta’s Cards and Hobbies, has been nestled in the back of his parents’ carpet store for a year and a half.