The Fourth of July: America’s birthday. That was the day in 1776 when the individual colonies decided to become one country. But, in truth, there was not much that was united about America at that time, and it has been a struggle ever since to create “one” America. It took the Civil War for the U.S. to even be referred to in the singular (“the United States is …” as opposed to the pre-1865 “the United States are …”).

It was never clear in the decades after the Revolutionary War if the new nation could hold together for very long.