Right at the end of Tuesday afternoon’s Christmas music program at the Cecil Collins Elementary School in Barnegat Township, Santa Claus entered through a door into the packed all-purpose room. He high-fived numerous students on the stage and greeted others standing nearby. But then as he approached one particular youngster, the man in the big red suit took off his cap and white beard and gave him a hug.

The boy was Ayden Attwood, a first-grader at the school, and the man playing Santa was his father, Frank Attwood, a…