On Good Friday afternoon, Ship Bottom Mayor William Huelsenbeck and Anthony Mautone Jr., the borough’s magistrate, went out on a boat in the bay to do a little fishing. But it soon got a little too windy, and they headed back.

But while returning, their curiosity was aroused when they saw a bucket sitting on the edge of an area known as Flat Island off 27th Street. Under thebucket were seaweed, debris and an old, glass Diet Pepsi bottle.