In the late 1800s, oysters were a booming industry in the Little Egg Harbor area. The Tuckerton Railroad would carry barrels of them to Whiting, where they would be put on trains to fish markets in Philadelphia and New York. By the 1920s the oyster stock was depleted and never came back in force. A combination of overharvesting, eelgrass depletion, salinity change and the oyster diseases MSX and dermo ended the boom. Clams took the place of oysters in the local economy.

However, another function of oysters, not suspected centuries ago, is their ability to filter impurities from the bay.