Let’s make one thing immediately clear: you’re not likely to see a collection of talent such as Surflight Theatre has assembled for its current production, “Boynton Beach Club,” in many theaters outside of New York City.

The cast of 12 can boast more than 40 Broadway appearances. It includes stars such as Andrea McArdle, the original Annie; Joel Blum, twice nominated for a Tony as best featured actor in a musical for his work in “Show Boat” and “Steel Pier”; and Barry Pearl, who played Randolph…