To the Editor:

In response to the Nov. 8 Commentary “Sandy Proves Replenishment Is Strategic Failure,” the writer is delusional or has some other agenda. The dunes clearly played a significant role in protecting the Island, not just beachfront homes or a tiny minority of people, but the entire Island. And building larger dunes is a primary goal of beach replenishment here on Long Beach Island.

Mr. Ryan is writing to the effect that replenishment was an option that failed.

November 14, 2012