People at the shore love pirate tales. So the history goes thatat the end of the 17th century, Capt. Kidd had just failed to secure a commission in Britain’s Royal Navy. Dejected, he returned to his home in New York City with a new plan in mind. After being persuaded by his close friends and associates, Kidd received a privateering license to attack and plunder wealthy French ships, securing loot and splitting it amongst his crew and the crown.

Kidd and his crew quickly grew disillusioned by privateering and were increasingly frustrated with their orders to…