On an overcast September Monday, the Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station scrammed one final time, shutting down with the rapid insertion of control rods, and ending nearly five decades of nuclear energy production at the Lacey Township-based plant. Even as company and town officials termed the day somber, discussions about what could potentially replace the nuke were already underway.

“We knew this day was coming,” Gary Quinn, a former five-term Lacey Township mayor and current township committeeman,…