Our Gang Players, Southern Ocean County’s longest-running community theater troupe (it was founded in 1977), usually plays it pretty close to the vest when picking its shows for the year. Sherry Schnepp, the group’s co-founder and artistic director, knows her audiences and what will draw and also realizes that Our Gang needs to put fannies in the seats if it is to survive, especially when benefactors are spreading their donations to post-Sandy causes.

Our Gang’s 2013 lineup, therefore, features classics, such as the dark comedy “Arsenic and Old Lace” in February,…