Ask six people how to make the “best” sangria, and expect to get six very different answers. Some say the defining ingredient is citrus; some say brandy; some drink it straight, or over ice, or mixed with soda.

The good news? They’re all right!

As The Beachcomber crowns sangria Long Beach Island’s favorite cocktail for summer 2015, here are some insights from a few different experts on that alluring elixir that combines wine, fruit and a splash of creative whimsy.