The New Gretna Old Home Society maintains two cemeteries in the town, the historic Hillside Cemetery off Old New York Road and the newer Miller Cemetery on Maple Avenue. Traditionally, the Methodist church maintained the Hillside and the Presbyterian church maintained the Miller, but in 1921 the Old Home Society was formed to take care of both cemeteries.

According to local historian Peter Stemmer, it was named the Old Home Society because many New Gretna citizens had left the small town on the…