Mr. LoveJoy founder Richie Moscola has been jamming at Nardi’s Tavern & Grille on Long Beach Island since 1995, and the crowd, along with the familiar atmosphere, never seems to get old. After being in a successful Jersey Shore cover band called Dog Voices for many years, Moscola formed Mr. LoveJoy in 2012 with Rob Monte, who is no longer with the band.

The lineup has since expanded and now includes Moscola, who is a guitarist, bassist and singer; lead vocalist and bassist Dylan Kelehan; drummer…