Like most 20-year-olds juggling work and financial stability, Brie Fagan of Manahawkin found the sea glass and natural crystal and gemstone jewelry she loved to wear was simply out of her price range. But her thrifty nature and passion for all things handmade, fueled as a child by her grandmother’s artistic flair, has beckoned her to begin crafting the jewelry herself. She opened her own Etsy shop in August, called The Wandering Gypsea, where she sells most of her wares.

Inspired by the beaches of Fagan’s hometown near Long Beach Island, the handcrafted necklaces, bracelets, rings,…