Jonathan Oldham, who has been mayor so long he can’t remember but it’s “close to 25 years,” summed up the qualities that make Harvey Cedars unique: its smallness, its quaint business community and its longstanding traditions. At just about2 square miles, residents are “more apt to know everybody,” he said.

The High Point Volunteer Fire Co. and the borough Activity Committee are integral to the town’s identity as a place where memories are made, be it at the annual Dog Day Road Race (marking its…