I’m not one for nostalgia. My tastes in music and “Seinfeld” repeats keep me trapped in the past as it is. I don’t need any extra help to bottle me up in a single decade. But with St. Patrick’s Day approaching, the itch to revisit a beer from my past, a beer I had moved on from long ago, was hard to ignore. And when the impulse to grab a four-pack of Guinness Draught hit me, I decided to turn it a into research project: Does anyone else share my gripe about Guinness?

The short answer is yes. In the craft beer era – with its abundant choices and flavors – Guinness Draught, the classic…