Long Beach Island is a pretty casual place. Actually, LBI is a very casual place, especially when it comes to dress. Shorts and T-shirts dominate during the summer. Jackets and neckties not only are not required in even the Island’s best restaurants, but stick out; little black dresses live a lonely life, pining away in closets.

More than a decade ago, when the Our Gang Players, Southern Ocean County’s longest-running community theater troupe, was trying to come up with a fundraising idea,…