“My first year teaching, like many people’s first year of teaching, was staggeringly traumatic. For somebody to go to Princeton, and then get a job, and feel like they’re totally unprepared, tells you something about the field,” admitted Sarah Tantillo, author of the recently published The Literacy Cookbook. “It was a challenge. I don’t want people to suffer the way I did,” she added with a laugh.

Based on many years of experience as a high school English and humanities teacher, as well as an educational consultant and founder and director of the New…