Watching the votes coming in for Barnegat Township from the Ocean County Clerk’s Office, the Independent tandem of Denise Pilovsky and Bill Cox had thoughts that they might be able to defeat theRepublican slate of Mayor Susan McCabe and Frank Caputo. But after the votes from the final districts were counted, the Republicans ended up with a close win. Caputo, a former school board member, led all vote-getters with 1,717, while McCabe received 1,635 votes.