When Bonnie and Al Poling moved to their late-19th-century Victorian on Route 9 in Eagleswood this year, they brought with them a holiday attraction to make passing motorists smile.

The live-animal manger scene was a tradition for the couple for more than 20 years at their previous residence in Jackson. On the lot next to their house, a fence enclosure contains two alpacas and one llama, a handful of regular sheep, a goat and a donkey, grazing around while figures of Mary and Joseph, newborn…