The closing of Surflight Theatre and its accompanying Show Place Ice Cream Parlour in Beach Haven comes as a shock to many local residents and visitors who have fond memories of the venues. But for Allentown, Pa., resident Robert Woroniak, 80, and his family, who have been making trips to the area since the 1970s, “Broadway at the Beach” will continue as they make their sixth excursion to The Cast House in April.

A 4,200-square-foot building that includes 10 Broadway-themed bedrooms and bathrooms, The Cast House, also located in…