Who makes the best sugar cookie in Bay Villageand Schooner’s Wharf in Beach Haven? Apparently, it’s Country Kettle Fudge, which was voted best by holiday shoppers converging on the area last Saturday.

Coming in second was Chick’s LBI Shop, while Buddy’s Pet Stop was voted third. This was the fourth year of the competition.

“I made elephant ears,” said Julia Kurdyla of Country Kettle. “I used brown sugar and cinnamon.”

Other participants were Will it be Breezin’ Up, Song of the Sea, Beached, Yuletide, Spice It Up, Ship Bottom Brewery,…