When Gretchen and John Coyle set out for a Florida vacation in October, they prepared their Beach Haven home for an upstairs renovation, taking all the artwork off the walls and moving it carefully to the downstairs living areas. The next weekend, Superstorm Sandy struck.

“We lost everything on the first floor,” said Gretchen Coyle. When the authorities opened Beach Haven to residents, “our friends, Deb Whitcraft and her husband, Jim Vogel, went and retrieved what they could; there were decoys…