Sitting in one of the pews inside the old Manahawkin Baptist Church on Dec. 17, Harold Fargo gently gripped his chin as he gazed toward the platform in the back of the church, from where the sweet sound of a group of Southern Regional High School students echoed throughout the single-room building.

“I just knew there would be some caroling going on,” said Fargo, the brother of Kelly Rohrer, whose family was the beneficiary of the “Caroling for the Rohrer Family” fundraiser event, which…