On the quieter, residential streets of Long Beach Island in the summer, families with beach houses on the same block get to know each other and grow together over the years. They meet on the beach, kids play together in the summers, and neighborly bonds are formed.

On Ninth Street in Surf City, a set of neighbors have started a tradition of celebrating that bond with an annual backyard party, complete with live entertainment provided by their teenage boys, three of whom have formed as the…