Carrie Merritt finished several minutes behind the overall winner during the Ugly Christmas Sweater 5K, but she won perhaps the most important prize at the third annual fundraising event for All Saints Regional Catholic School on Dec. 3. She was the top female vote-getter for the “best” ugly sweater, or in her case complete get-up.

“I’m a first-grade teacher, so I make costumes for everything,” said the 37-year-old from Ocean City, who also won the then-overall award for her costume two years…